Guest Stars Keegan Connor Tracy as Blue Fairy / Mother Superior Michael Raymond-James as Neal Cassidy / Baelfire David Anders as Dr. Victor Frankenstein / Dr. Whale Chris Gauthier as William Smee Ethan Embry as outsider Sonequa Martin-Green as Tamara Dylan Schmid as Baelfire Freya Tingley as Wendy Darling Andrew Airlie as George Darling Co Starring William Ainscough as John Benjamin Cook as Michael Karin Inghammar as Mary