Guest Stars David Arquette as Randy Mann Debra Mooney as Calista Cod Dana Davis as Barb Alexandra Barreto as Veronica Villanueva Hayes MacArthur as Buddy Amicus Co Starring Stevie Wash, Jr. as Young Emerson Colton Haynes as Ares Phil Abrams as Dr. Eugene Halifax J.R. Nutt as Teen Buddy Joshua LeBar as Joe Carolyn McDermott as Brave Faced Wife Heather Brooker as Missy Scrivner Amelia Borella as Young Calista