Guest Stars Ken Marino as Jason "C.J." Stentley Jim O'Heir as Sheriff Reynolds Eric Roberts as Jimmy "The Butcher" Figgis Co Starring Biff Wiff as Tito Kent Shocknek as Slade Austin Bo Kane as John Lux Victoria Recaño as Brynn DeRose Payam Banifaz as Rob Zedric Harris as Deputy #1 Karen Y. McClain as Ann Lurks Doreene Hamilton as Gemma