Guest Stars Pruitt Taylor Vince as J.J. LaRoche Rebecca Wisocky as Brenda Shettrick Dennis Cockrum as Cellmate Mike Doyle as Mason Braverman Meg Foster as Judith Saynay Meagen Fay as Joanne Parsons Aimee-Lynn Chadwick as Sarah Parsons Keith Pillow as Forensic Pathologist Lisa Pescia as Prison Administrator Co Starring Karl Sonnenberg as CBI Karl Michael Rubenstone as Tupperware Man Micah Nelson as Tupperware Boy Mark Dippolito as Scott Saynay