Special Guest Stars Graham Beckel as Juror Guest Stars Jerry O'Connell as Detective Woodrow "Woody" Hoyt Susan Gibney as DA Renee Walcott Lawrence Pressman as Judge Harlan Marshall Armin Shimerman as Dr. McCain Jonathan Adams as Juror Alan Dale as Carl Logan Bertila Damas as Juror Claudette Sutherland as Mrs. Logan Jesse Corti as Detective Al Morris Starletta DuPois as Juror Co Starring Ken Jeong as Steve Choi Meera Simhan as Zuleda Salman Kareem Grimes as Pat Simmons Bob Glouberman as Joe Rosenblatt Hector Luis Bustamante as Pete Delgado Dean Nolen as Attorney Hagen Bryce Lenon as Jake Logan Kim Evey as Simone Muang Toya A. Brown as Court Officer Antonia Jones as Sylvia Thompson David Ripley as Ainsworth