Co Starring Fred Stinson as Life Sized Puppet Jawbone Robert Mills as Life Sized Puppet Jawbone Fred Stinson as Life Size Horace Horrible Robert Mills as Life Size Horace Horrible Tristan Carlucci as Jawbone Stunt Costume Garth Merkeley as Jawbone Stunt Costume Cassandra Consiglio as The Tooth Child Olivier De Sagazan as The Skin-Taker Connor Peterson as Jacob Booth BJ Verot as Mike Stunt Double Karen Valleau voices Pirate Percy Puppet Tara Koehler as Young Mrs. Booth Jessica Loeppky as Chloe Benson Benjamin James Judson as Tommy Hasbrook Lauren Mestito-Dao as Sofia Reyes Keenan Lehmann as Alex Fry Annika Irving as Sadie Williams Conan Hodgkinson as Carl Cutter Mackenzie Wojcik as Gene Hazel Greyden Bohotchuk as Young Gary Gwendolyn Collins as Daphne Bell David Lawrence Brown as Tim Hazel Bronagh Waugh as Young Marla Kevin Klassen as Mike & Eddie's Father Susan Kelso as Mrs. Keller Ross Maxwell as Gary Stunt Double Darren Ross as Tim Stunt Double Christopher MacMillan as Gene Stunt Double