Special Guest Stars Billy Burke as Jake McCoy Guest Stars Chris Agos as Assistant State's Attorney Steve Kot Barbara Eve Harris as Commander Emma Crowley Kevin Kane as Officer Mike Sorensen Violett Beane as Maya Collins Matt McTighe as Freddy Mays Co Starring Malkia Stampley as Vicky Metzler Karin Anglin as Alexa Grant Sophia Ntovas as Marley McCoy Richard Esteras as Clerk Kristy Acosta as Waitress Kenneth Raskin as Manny Johanna McKenzie Miller as Sharon McCoy Scott Duff as Mr. Jones Katie Monds as Alicia Meyers Calvin Evans as Saint Larry Neumann, Jr. as John Dolan