Guest Stars Jeffrey Dean Morgan as Geoffrey Pine Courtnee Draper as Melissa Sumner Co Starring Agam Darshi as Dawn Pullman Craig March as Paisley Tie Jessica Schreier as Helene Clarke Gwenda Lorenzetti as Mrs. Sumner Alfred E. Humphreys as Mr. Sumner Fabrice Grover as Poker Playing Man #2 Jodie Graham as Bartender Alex Bland as Wendy Sumner Dave Brass as Poker Playing Man