Guest Stars Marie Avgeropoulos as Kirstie Nelson Jeffrey Pierce as Stuart Reynolds Shauna Johannesen as Meadow Christian Michael Cooper as Andy Ben Hollingsworth as Peter Grey Eric Lange as Cameron Spencer Locke as Carey Mandeville Al Miro as Detective Chad L. Coleman as True Believer #4 Danielle Kremeniuk as Woman Handler Layton Keely as True Believer #2 Jason Cermak as Figure #1 Benjamin Rogers as Figure #2 Megan Danso as True Believer #1 Nick Hunnings as Crew Man Ian Harmon as Male Handler Todd Thomson as Photographer Jameson Trenholm as True Believer #3 Michael Tiernan as Big Man Erik Eidem as Miller Michelle Wilson as New Initiate Woman Jack Forrester as Paz's Son Gilles Tanguay as Jailer