Recurring Guest Characters God 38 guest appearances Danielle Kartes 21 guest appearances Matt Iseman 13 guest appearances Fortune Feimster 9 guest appearances Jay Leno 8 guest appearances Meghan Trainor 8 guest appearances Blake Shelton 8 guest appearances Joel McHale 7 guest appearances Duff Goldman 7 guest appearances Courtney Rich 7 guest appearances Guy Branum 7 guest appearances Chef 7 guest appearances John Legend 6 guest appearances Neil deGrasse Tyson 6 guest appearances Mario Lopez 6 guest appearances Max Greenfield 6 guest appearances Kit Hoover 6 guest appearances Nick Jonas 6 guest appearances Seth Meyers 6 guest appearances Whitney Cummings 6 guest appearances ⇤ « 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 » ⇥