All-Star Cakemas!
Episode: 1x01 | Airdate: Nov 28, 2024 (41 min)
Three all-stars create mind-blowing decoys of reindeer, nutcrackers and holiday wreaths. Guest judges: Rachel Bloom, Wayne Brady and Sebastian Maniscalco.
Season 1
Snow Many Cakes
Episode: 1x02 | Airdate: Nov 28, 2024 (39 min)
In a jolly quest for redemption, a trio of past runner-ups replicates snow-day essentials. Guest judges: Hannah Berner, Tiffany Haddish and Devon Walker.
Season's Eatings
Episode: 1x03 | Airdate: Nov 28, 2024 (39 min)
Turkey, ham and fondue are on the menu in this battle for a spot in the finale. Guest judges: James Austin Johnson, Chris Witaske and Sasheer Zamata.
Tis the Season for a Winner
Episode: 1x04 | Airdate: Nov 28, 2024 (41 min)
The all-stars face a festive finale first: creating stunning interactive treats for the win! Guest judges: Terry Crews, Punkie Johnson and Randall Park.
Season 2
A Very Merry Cakemas
Episode: 2x01 | Airdate: Nov 25, 2025 (40 min)
"Is It Cake?" all-star artisans make a sweet salute to their favorite holiday memories for judges Wendi McLendon-Covey, Dustin Milligan and Kel Mitchell.
It’s a Wonderful Cake
Episode: 2x02 | Airdate: Nov 25, 2025 (39 min)
A second batch of all-star bakers pay a sugary homage to their cherished traditions. Can they fool judges Kristen Bell, Pierson Fodé and Lamorne Morris?
A Winner Wonderland
Episode: 2x03 | Airdate: Nov 25, 2025 (40 min)
For their finale showdown, bakers must sculpt meticulous desserts fit to spin in a display window for judges Lacey Chabert, King Bach and Michael Urie.