Guest Stars Lucy Davis as Lucy Kenwright Ayda Field as Jeannie Whatley Simon Helberg as Alex Dwyer John Ennis as Denny Wendy Phillips as Shelley Green Michael Hyatt as Maisey Mircea Monroe as Crystal Rob Nagle as Moderator Co Starring Nate Torrence as Dylan Killington Camille Chen as Samantha Li John F. Carpenter as Herb Sheldon William Stanford Davis as Floor Manager Kirstin Pierce as Marylyn Rudolph Tom Ayers as Participant Nathan Dana Aldrich as Fan Bayani Ison as Concierge Uncredited Rob Reiner as Himself (Studio 60 Host)
