Guest Stars Michael Mastro as Judge M. Serani Michael Kostroff as Attorney Evan Braun Casey Cott as Lucas Hale Kip Pardue as Reverend Gary Langham Orlagh Cassidy as Cheryl Davenport Tom Titone as Judge Joshua Goldfarb Zachary Knower as Mr. Davenport Jessie Carter as Ann Davenport Sarah Deaver as Lydia Banks Co Starring Erica Camarano as Officer Rachel Ortiz Peter Graham as Brad Alexander Hodge as Trent Dillon Rebecca Krainik as Charlotte Owens David Julian Levi as Dave Uncredited Steve Zirnkilton voices Opening Narration