Guest Stars Ari Graynor as Rachel Dunham Felix Solis as Daniel Hicks Neal Huff as Marshall Bowman Armando Riesco as Gavin Co Starring Lily Pilblad as Ella Blake Darby Totten as Agent Simmons Ash Roeca as Agent Rodriguez Guiesseppe Jones as FBI Agent Olivia Jones as Flight Attendant Melissa Mike Realba as Male Flight Attendant Judy Sinclair as Woman on Plane Al Sapienza as Conrad Moreau Chris LaPanta as Gavin's Man #1 Dina Ann Comolli as Mom Uncredited Michael Cerveris as September