Guest Stars C.S. Lee as Vince Masuka Christina Robinson as Astor Bennett Daniel Goldman as Cody Bennett Christian Camargo as Rudy Cooper Mark Pellegrino as Paul Bennett Dominic Janes as Young Dexter Laura Marano as Young Debra Kathrin Middleton as Doris Morgan Dakin Matthews as Dr. Pittman Joseph Lyle Taylor as Sgt. McKay Co Starring Jeanette Miller as Old Neighbor Winston Story as Messenger Andrew Caple-Shaw as Resident Lance Irwin as Uniformed Cop Dion Blake Vines as Security Guard Uncredited Frank Tedesco as Miami Dade Police Officer
