Guest Stars Dennis Boutsikaris as Josh Beekman Deborah Hedwall as Lieutenant Wade Bobby Cannavale as Joe Leo Burmester as Father Peter Castoro Jamie Harrold as Niall Charlie Hofheimer as Tommy Morissey Amy Ryan as Siobhan Malik Yoba as Sam Davis Kevin Carolan as Desk Sgt. Bonfiglio Sarah Rafferty as Sarah Debra Monk as Mrs. Morissey Deirdre Lovejoy as Karen Sealey J.D. Williams as Malik Lynda Gravatt as Mrs. Evans Beau Gravitte as Mr. Morissey Danton Stone as Tony DiGiovanni Priscilla Shanks as Mrs. Gardner John Horton as Grievous Myra Lucretia Taylor as Leslie Yulkowski David Adkins as Harry Coogan Jesse Doran as Tim Foley P.J. Brown as TBD Tommy Hollis as Mr. Evans E. Katherine Kerr as Judge James Judy as Bill Riley Frank Vogt as Jason Greyson Erik Pendry as Kyle