Guest Stars Nik Dodani as Zahid Raja Graham Rogers as Evan Chapin Raúl Castillo as Nick Co Starring Jenna Boyd as Paige Hardaway Wendy Braun as Kathy Kevin Daniels as Coach Briggs Michelle Farrah Huang as Tanya Stacey Moseley as Shelby Pines Monnae Michaell as Michelle Clare Leahy as Cashier Brittney Bertier as Ponytail girl Uncredited Jessica Marshall-Gardiner as Paige's Teacher