Guest Stars Caleel Harris as Young Henry Deaver Adam Rothenberg as Reverend Matthew Deaver Noel Fisher as Dennis Zalewski Ann Cusack as Warden Theresa Porter Cassady McClincy Zhang as Young Molly Strand Chris Coy as Boyd Charlie Tahan as Dean Merrill Russell Posner as Derek Mark Zeisler as Cal Burke Moses as Corey Co Starring Nada Despotovich as Bartender Alexander W. Pollock as Pierre Thomas Rhett Kee as Cop Kyla Packard as Little Girl Khloe Packard as Little Girl Colton Osorio as Nose Picker Harper Pilat as Doodler Jack Brunault as Bailiff Reese Grande Jefts as Coroner Trip Case as Prosecutor James DeFilippi as Defendant
