Guest Stars Amanda Leighton as Emma Kurtzman Tom Williamson as AJ Hensdale Elliot Fletcher as Aaron Baker Meg DeLacy as Grace Mullen Lisseth Chavez as Ximena Sinfuego Kalama Epstein as Noah Walker Christopher Meyer as Logan Bayfield Nandy Martin as Poppy Sinfuego Nia Peeples as Susan Mullen Chris McGarry as Agent Allen Scott Broderick as Agent Estes / ICE Agent #1 Hugo Garcia as Juan Sinfuego Leticia Jimenez as Maria Theresa Sinfuego Joy Osmanski as Dr. Choi Jean Louisa Kelly as Pastor Nicole Alex Quijano as Tony Delgado Joi Liaye as Olivia