Guest Stars Caleel Harris as Young Henry Deaver Adam Rothenberg as Reverend Matthew Deaver Aaron Staton voices Reverend Appleton Cassady McClincy Zhang as Young Molly Strand Chosen Jacobs as Wendell Deaver Rory Culkin as Willie Mark Harelik as Gordon CJ Jones as Odin Branch Jayne Atkinson as Daria Reese Lauren Bowles as Lola Michael Rodrick as Student Julienne Hanzelka Kim as Teagan Rodrigo Lopresti as Gaddis Co Starring Mathilde Dehaye as Amity Lambert Thomas Rhett Kee as Cop Johnny Lee Davenport as Professor #1 Lance Norris as Driver Rebecca Huerta as EMT
