Guest Stars Michael Rispoli as Wilkie Kyle Bornheimer as Paul Chris Jameson as Core Clerical Sophie Guest as Haley Vogel Aubree Stone as Amy Cavallo Roe Hartrampf as Todd Heinicke Douglas Roberts as Jogger JD Phillips as Mike Dredan McFall as Trevor Keith Michael Gregory as Patrick Albreath Faust Checho as Mark Angelo Jake Andolina as Bailiff John Calvin Doyle as AA Member Jordan Trovillion as Monica Albreath