Guest Stars Aya Cash as Joan Simon Jake Lacy as Ron Nate Corddry as Neil Simon Bianca Marroquín as Chita Rivera Danny Burstein as Dr. Littman Co Starring Juliet Brett as Nicole Fosse Paloma Garcia-Lee as Adrienne Peter Chursin as Christopher Chadman Heather Lang as Sandy Ari Brand as Danny Bahiyah Hibah as Candy Brown Matt Wall as Fred Ebb A.J. Holmes as John Kander Sean Patrick Doyle as Michael O'Haughey Aaron Krohn as Henry Tyler Hanes as Jerry Orbach Sydni Beaudoin as Lori Howard W. Overshown as Bill Teddy Coluca as Herb Schlein José Ramón Rosario as Carlos J.C. Schuster as Conductor / MC Pamela Sousa as Ballet Mistress Alvin Keith as Internist Pamela Mitchell as Marsha Mason