Guest Stars Noelle Renée Bercy as Evita Miles Mussenden as Otis Johnson Dilshad Vadsaria as Avandalia "Lia" Dewan Ally Maki as Mina Hess Brooklyn McLinn as Andre Deschaine Lane Miller as Fuchs Jaime Zevallos as Father Francis Delgado Joshua J. Williams as Solomon Cecilia Leal as Mikayla Kiley Casciano as Aliza Co Starring Andy Dylan as Nathan Bowen John Fertitta as State Senator Asa Henderson Askia Bennett as David