Guest Stars Liza Lapira as Mia Dale Dickey as RoseMarie Omar Maskati as Elias Kai Lennox as Steve Rasmussen Eric Lange as Detective Parker Scott Lawrence as Special Agent Billy Taggart Elizabeth Marvel as Judith Max Arciniega as Jason Alvarez Patricia Fa'Asua as Becca Jun Hee Lee as Officer Geoffrey Morris Annaleigh Ashford as Lilly Darrow Bill Fagerbakke as Detective Pruitt Aaron Staton as Curtis McCarthy Graham Hamilton as James Massey Co Starring Blake Ellis as Chris McCarthy Connor Tillman as Officer Selig Tim Martin Gleason as Bennett John Hartmann as Hughes Alison Jaye as Nicole Dejon LaQuake as Ryan Elena Campbell-Martinez as Judge Costas Aiden Randall as Ricardo Kya Kruse as Nadia Omar Ghonim as FBI Tech Veronica St. Clair as Girlfriend Fay Wolf as Receptionist Ashton Moio as Wasted Trust Fund Guy Eric Henry as Cashier Victoria Garcia-Kelleher as Soccer Mom Rueben Grundy as Sergeant Zellner Melissa Jo Bailey as DMV Lady Christopher Chen as DMV Tester Trevor Lee Georgeson as Bartender Jeff Marchelletta as WM Police Chief Devin Crittenden as Wasted Preppy Girl