Guest Stars Erin Moriarty as Audrey Hart Dana Gourrier as Cathleen J.D. Evermore as Det. Lutz Anthony Molina as Detective Don Yesso as Commander Speece Lili Simmons as Beth Brighton Sharbino as Maisie Hart Jay O. Sanders as Rev. Billy Lee Tuttle Shea Whigham as Joel Theriot Louis Herthum as Terry Guidry Paul Ben-Victor as Major Leroy Salter Kerry Cahill as Nurse Azure Parsons as Charmaine Boudreaux Daniel Ross Owens as William Mayo Rio Hackford as Bruce Gabe Begneaud as Drew Ledger December Ensminger as Kelly Reider Tim Hanks as Prison Guard Tom O'Connell as Junior Detective Henry Frost as Steve