Special Guest Stars Janet Leigh as Miss Diketon Guest Stars Jack Palance as Louis Strago Allen Jenkins as Enzo "Pretty" Stilletto Letícia Román as Pia Monteri Jack La Rue as Federico "Feet" Stilletto Eduardo Ciannelli as Arturo "Fingers" Stilletto Co Starring Elisha Cook as Arnold Ludwig Donath as Dr. Von Kronen Penny Santon as Grandmama Monteri Maxie Rosenbloom as Crunch Battaglia Vince Barnett as Scissors Clarke Gordon as Officer Will Kuluva as Mr. Thaler Credit Only Frank Puglia as Padre Francisco Uncredited Hank Robinson as Thrush Agent Jerry Schumacher as Thrush Agent Michelle Breeze as Party Guest