Guest Stars Damien Garvey as Mr. Roper Marissa Stott as Tattoo Girl / Lucy Phil Peleton as Kelly's Father Bridget Hoffman as Little Lori Mike Edward as John Carson Jennifer Freed as Woman in Bar Shara Connolly as TV Reporter James Gaylyn as Waiter Sian Davis as Vivian Johnson Brian Satterfield as Bartender Matilda Garbett as Girl in Diner