Guest Stars Jarod Joseph as Nathan Miller Sachin Sahel as Eric Jackson Adina Porter as Indra Luisa d'Oliveira as Emori Lola Flanery as Madi Jessica Harmon as Niylah Ivana Miličević as Charmaine Diyoza John Pyper-Ferguson as Bill Cadogan Jason Diaz as Levitt Neal McDonough as First Disciple Anders Co Starring Luc Roderique as Penn Tom Stevens as Trey Adam Lolacher as Jeremiah Xavier de Guzman as Knight Sean Quan as Rex Max Montesi as Lindo the Defector Max Archibald as Believer Boy Josh Collins as Otis Leah Hennessey as Luca's Mother Michelle C. Smith as Cell Block Guard