Guest Stars Carina Battrick as Caroline Cross Barbara Alyn Woods as Michelle Cross Devon Sawa as Logan Wheeler Michael Therriault as Nathan Cross Lexa Doig as Bree Wheeler Rachelle Casseus as Detective Evans Jana Peck as Principal McVey Travis Milne as Detective Peyton Devon Sawa as Lucas Wheeler Co Starring Annie Briggs as Miss Fairchild Nick A. Fisher voices Good Guy Doll David Kohlsmith as Young Charles Lee Ray Avery Esteves as Oliver Hayden Marisa McIntyre as Elizabeth Ray Precious Chong as Mrs. Jolly Marcus Cornwall as Cute Boy