Guest Stars Randy Flagler as Firefighter Harold Capp Katelynn Shennett as Kylie Estevez Tim Hopper as Captain Tom Van Meter Andy Allo as Lieutenant Wendy Seager LaRoyce Hawkins as Kevin Atwater Brett Dalton as Lieutenant Jason Pelham Halie Robinson as Cara Marceline Hugot as Sister Montclair Co Starring Anthony Ferraris as Squad 3 Driver Tony Ferraris Brigid Duffy as Mrs. Callahan Rey Hernandez as Orton Damian Thompson as Father Marcus Phoebe A. Hill as 5-Year-Old Girl Mark D. Hines as Larry Muller Shayla Day as Factory Manager Mindy Bell as Parishioner Larry Neumann, Jr. as Father Phil Annabel Armour as Mrs. Muller