Special Guest Stars Haylie Duff as Stevie Marx Guest Stars Aaron Himelstein as Friedman Mark Totty as Det. Carlisle Elaine Hendrix as Ms. Lischak Constance Zimmer as Sister Lilly Watters Annie Potts as Lt. Lucy Preston Juliette Goglia as Little Girl God Mark Matkevich as Roger Jordan David as Geek God Gil Glasgow as Mr. Ward Michelle Gardner as Substitute Teacher God Co Starring Justin Scot as Officer Eicher Susan Grace as Mrs. Gross Rick Fitts as Paul Brumfield