Guest Stars Jeff Hiller as Mr. Whitely Brian Ray Norris as Detective Mulcahey Taylor Bloom as Stewart Chris Henry Coffey as Patrick's Father Kieran Brown as Young Patrick Co Starring Matthew William Bishop as Big Daddy John Bubniak as Freddy Kyle Dunn as Danny Danny Kornfeld as Billy Tyler Johnson Ellis as Beautiful Young Man India Chappell-Wanebo as Assistant Will T. Travis as Steve Kevin Paul Woods as Wall Street Exec Ned Noyes as Priest Colin Chapin as Patrick's Roommate Kevin Dean Williams as Doctor Brian David Tracy as Sam's Father