Guest Stars Deirdre Lovejoy as Cynthia Panabaker Teddy Coluca as Teddy Brimley Alex Brightman as Herbie Hambright Stacy Keach as Robert Vesco Neal Huff as Lucas Roth Jacob Pitts as Quentin Dodd Guy Lockard as Special Agent Will Strickland Gene Jones as Pops Sean McDermott as Jerry Hayes Chantal Jean-Pierre as Bookseller Co Starring Joy Sudduth as Star Christopher Piccione as Inmate Iliana Inocencio as Journalist Sebastian Arroyo as Special Agent Sanz Ken King as Special Agent Ives Greg Balla as Uniformed Cop Connor Ausman as AJ