Guest Stars Daniel K. Isaac as Lieutenant Steve Connor Daniel Oreskes as Detective Buzz Fleming Daniel Davis as Dr. Yablonski Christian Borle as Carter Schmidt Nathan Lane as Phillip Cross Corey Mach as Eddie Reese Co Starring Jaime Schwarz as Mandy Kiaya Scott as Michelle Kario Marcel as Sean Janine Morita Colletti as Cio-Cio San Bethany Ann Tesarck as Pam Giuseppe Ardizzone as Baron Scarpia Lauren Cafrelli as Tosca Katherine Penny as Lisa DeAnna Supplee as Uniformed Officer Christopher Borg as Gino Gozzi Olivia Puckett as Alexa Anne-Marie Cusson as Jesse the Usher Nick Sullivan as Fritz
