Guest Stars Daniel K. Isaac as Lieutenant Steve Connor Daniel Oreskes as Detective Buzz Fleming Jenn Colella as Captain Kershaw Ethan Slater as Officer Reese Chandler David Alan Grier as Arthur Greene Jr. Jenn Harris as Barb Joshua Echebiri as Russell Greene Kate Easton as Juniper Dell Charles Turner as Raymond Greene Co Starring Delissa Reynolds as Lucy Longacre Tim Connell as Mr. Barton Ruth Gottschall as Mrs. Barton Mackenzie Meadows as Heather Jake Bentley Young as College Bro Tibor Feldman as Shomer Donathan Walters as Don Mike Rob as Aaron Miles Jacoby as Agent Kane Tim Griffin Allan as Jay Anthony Fazio as Dominic Suzanne Toren as Mrs. Henderson
