Guest Stars Ben Levi Ross as Teddy Tascioni Gloria Reuben as Claudia Payne Michael Emerson as Judge Milton Crawford Jenn Colella as Captain Kershaw Meredith Holzman as Delia Kirby Braeden De La Garza as Detective Rivers Ava DeMary as Sherry Mitchell Pun Bandhu as Victor Landis Ethan Dubin as Young Milton Crawford Co Starring Alison Chace as Reporter Brian McCormack as Detective Hanes Martin Fisher as Court Officer Scott Drummond as Jordy Ian O'Boyle as Andy Mertens Zoe Mann as Laura
