Guest Stars Emma Caulfield as Anya Jenkins Kristine Sutherland as Joyce Summers Marc Blucas as Riley Finn Lindsay Crouse as Maggie Walsh Adam Kaufman as Parker Abrams Co Starring Aldis Hodge as Masked Teen Walter Jones as Edward Michele Nordin as Rachel Adam Grimes as Lobster Boy Adam Bitterman as Gachnar Darris Love as Hallmate Sulo Williams as Chaz Larissa Reynolds as Present Girl Marc Rose as Josh