Guest Stars Amber Benson as Tara Maclay Mercedes McNab as Harmony Kendall Charlie Weber as Ben Wilkinson Clare Kramer as Glory Amy Adams as Cousin Beth Steve Rankin as Mr. Maclay Co Starring Megan Gray as Sandy Kevin Rankin as Donny Brian Tee as Intern Ezra Buzzington as Bartender Peggy Goss as Crazy Person Torry Pendergrass as Damon