Guest Stars Zachary Booth as Michael Hewes Chris Messina as Chris Sanchez Judd Hirsch as Bill Herndon John Hannah as Rutger Simon Gillian Alexy as Gitta Novak Jenna Elfman as Naomi Walling LaTanya Richardson as Judge Jaclynn Ellis Co Starring Maya Days as Detective Rosario Ortiz Casey Siemaszko as Detective Dan Williams Brooke Liddell as Catherine Hewes Li Jun Li as Maggie Huang Kiley Liddell as Catherine Hewes Alexandra Socha as Rachel Walling JoAnna Rhinehart as Susan Marsden David Gautreaux as Bruce Davies James Riordan as British Interviewer Meredith Holzman as Cheryl Kohler McKenzie as Dave Joe Kernen as Squawk Box Host