Guest Stars Samuel Hunt as Craig "Mouse" Gurwitch David Eigenberg as Lieutenant Christopher Herrmann Oliver Platt as Dr. Daniel Charles Torrey DeVitto as Dr. Natalie Manning Jessica Rothe as Madison / Jaime Lynn Stevens Michael Torpey as Drew Stommer Rae Gray as Ruby Baker Co Starring Chris Agos as Assistant State's Attorney Steve Kot Mark Spates Smith as Pedestrian Matt Katzenmeier as Boyfriend Donn Carl Harper as Mailman Danielle Davis as Marcia Harris Marcos Barnes as Joaquin David Schwartzbaum as Clerk Evelyn Gaynor as Girlfriend
