Special Guest Stars Matthew Settle as Jonathan Sellers Guest Stars Luke Macfarlane as Scotty Wandell Kerris Dorsey as Paige Whedon Marika Dominczyk as Tyler Altamirano Josh Hopkins as Warren Salter David Burke as Jack Bishop Jay Huguley as Whit Peyton Tyler Posey as Gabriel Whedon Judith Moreland as Dr. Kate Allenby Janet Carroll as Sloane Dodelson Co Starring Maxwell Perry Cotton as Cooper Whedon Ryan Eggold as Randy Stewart Boo Arnold as Male Hotel Guest James Hornbeck as Harry Dodelson Michael Canavan as David Silver Diane Kim as Female Hotel Guest