Special Guest Stars Isabel Gillies as Kathy Stabler Steven Bauer as Raphael Gardner Guest Stars Andrea Weston as Woman Hisham Tawfiq as Firefighter #1 Sarah Marie Jenkins as Becca Jesse Schoem as Motel Clerk Mark Valley as Jake Keegan Anastasia Griffith as Leah Keegan Kevin Kolack as EMT Butler Lawrence Saint-Victor as Paramedic Jackson Lisa Jolley as Muriel David Teschendorf as Sheriff Johnson Jackie Judd as Jackie Judd Daniel Yelsky as Caleb Breville Eliza Foss as Mrs. Breville Tony Cucci as FDNY Captain Matthew Nicklaw as Matt Kramer Thomas Langston as Tommy Keegan Aisha de Haas as Female Paramedic Katy Finn as Kim Raymond Russell Hamlin as Man Korey Jackson as Gilbert Matthews Uncredited Steve Zirnkilton voices Opening Narration