Guest Stars Marla Sokoloff as Lucy Hatcher Richard McGonagle as Judge Patrick Wilcox Frank Birney as Judge Warren West Michael Monks as George Vogelman Edward Herrmann as Anderson Pearson Steven Gilborn as A.D.A. Gavin Bullock Francis X. McCarthy as Peter Robin Todd Sible as Steve Robin Austin Tichenor as A.D.A. Kenneth Tisbury Megan Cole as Meredith Pearson Paul Cassell as Jay Hickman David Selburg as Judge K. Holmes Kathryn Harrold as A.D.A. Jane Wharton Michael Kagan as Peter Martini Bob McCracken as Ron Harper Shiva Rose as Sally Bader James Noah as Appellate Judge Patterson William B. Jackson as Judge Watson Co Starring Michael Winder as Foreperson Uncredited Aimee Graham as Emma Paley