Guest Stars Jim Rash as Andrew Nick Kroll as El Chupacabra Jessie Camacho as Chupi Chupi Kulap Vilaysack as Stewardess 1 Patton Oswalt as Jillet-Ben Cole Jordan Peele as Three-Card Monte Guy Brendan Hunt as Soccer Hooligan A.D. Miles as Dr. Steve Wilson Eric Price as Delivery Guy Jane Park Smith as Stewardess 2