The Overuse of the Drama Genre


dpratt wrote 3 years ago: 1

In my opinion drama gets overused as a genre category, not just here, but on other web sites too. That is because almost any show has dramatic elements to it. So for drama to mean something, it should mean distressing and continuing problems for the main characters with emotion and the possibility of real harm.

I think overuse especially applies to shows that can be watched stand alone, that is where pretty much everything returns to normal by the end of the episode, and have only shallow drama compared to shows where main characters may have to face real ongoing difficulty. A good example here is the show Magnum PI where usually every episode wraps up with the mystery being solved and pretty much everything goes back to normal for the main characters.

Another example of overuse of the drama category is when bad things in general just do not happen to the main characters such as in kids shows. Adventure may be a better description in those cases.

The main reason I bring it up is because there is a maximum of three categories per show. And show editors should be careful before choosing drama as a category. Because there may be other better suited categories, especially if dramatic elements to the show are shallow and/or get wrapped up by the end of each episode. To me drama means that there is no status quo for the show to return to at the end of each episode and that main characters can therefore die, go to prison, or have to be hospitalized and that may be a continuing problem that main characters have to face. And therefore there is real suffering and/or danger facing the characters that continue from one episode to the next.


LadyShelley wrote 3 years ago: 2

The issue is most networks classify these shows and we are following their lead. CBS called Magnum PI a drama: 

MAGNUM P.I. is a modern take on the classic series centering on Thomas Magnum, a decorated former Navy SEAL who, upon returning home from Afghanistan, repurposes his military skills to become a private investigator. A charming rogue, an American hero and a die-hard Detroit Tigers fan, Magnum lives in a guest cottage on Robin’s Nest, the luxurious estate where he works as a security consultant to supplement his P.I. business. The “majordomo” of the property is Juliet Higgins, a beautiful and commanding disavowed MI:6 agent whose second job is to keep Magnum in line, with the help of her two Dobermans. When Magnum needs back-up on a job, he turns to his trusted buddies and fellow POW survivors, Theodore “TC” Calvin, a former Marine chopper pilot who runs Island Hoppers, a helicopter tour business, and Orville “Rick” Wright, a former Marine door-gunner-turned-impresario of Oahu’s coolest nightclub and the most connected man on the island. Suspicious of Magnum’s casual attitude and presence at his crime scenes, Detective Gordon Katsumoto finds that he and Magnum are more alike than either of them care to admit. One of Magnum’s biggest supporters is Teuila “Kumu” Tuileta, the unofficial “House Mom” and cultural curator of Robin’s Nest. With keys to a vintage Ferrari in one hand, aviator sunglasses in the other, and an Old Düsseldorf longneck chilling in the fridge, Thomas Magnum is back on the case!

Begins its fourth season Friday, Oct. 1 on the CBS Television Network and available to stream live and on demand on Paramount+.

ON AIR: Friday (9:00-10:00 PM, ET/PT)

ORIGINATION: Oahu, Hawaii

FORMAT: Drama (Filmed in HD)

The same is true for the various NCIS shows, FBI shows, Bull, Equaliser. 

Cecile wrote 3 years ago: 3

The reason is historical : by nature, any creative piece who isn't a comedy is a drama. If I remember correctly it comes from original live theater classification


dpratt wrote 3 years ago: 1

@Cecile wrote:
The reason is historical : by nature, any creative piece who isn't a comedy is a drama. If I remember correctly it comes from original live theater classification

If everything that isn't a comedy is a drama, then it goes without saying that it's a drama and we don't need to add drama to the list of genres for every show unless it is both a drama and a comedy or drama should be mentioned for other reasons.

While we're talking about Magnum PI, the reboot should have mystery added to the list of genres since in every episode Magnum solves a mystery. If you can't remove drama then please remove crime to make room for the mystery genre.

I used to watch that show but it got to the point where I couldn't watch it anymore, basically because it sucks so bad.


LadyShelley wrote 3 years ago: 1

@dpratt wrote:
If everything that isn't a comedy is a drama, then it goes without saying that it's a drama and we don't need to add drama to the list of genres for every show unless it is both a drama and a comedy or drama should be mentioned for other reasons.

While we're talking about Magnum PI, the reboot should have mystery added to the list of genres since in every episode Magnum solves a mystery. If you can't remove drama then please remove crime to make room for the mystery genre.

I used to watch that show but it got to the point where I couldn't watch it anymore, basically because it sucks so bad.

He's solving crimes as much as solving mysteries. Either one works. 


dpratt wrote 3 years ago: 1

@LadyShelley wrote:
He's solving crimes as much as solving mysteries. Either one works. 

Not every episode is about a crime. Every episode is however about a mystery.

deleted wrote 3 years ago: 1

@dpratt wrote:
Not every episode is about a crime. Every episode is however about a mystery.

It is how you define mystery though, though as our policy uses Magnum PI as an example for Mystery, I'd be willing to change drama into mystery.



Aidan wrote 3 years ago: 3

IMO, drama is a better fit for Magnum.
It's a vanilla procedural type show with a forgettable case of week and the main focus is the lives and relationships of the main characters.

And the solving a case bit is already covered by the crime genre tag.


LadyShelley wrote 3 years ago: 1

@Thomas wrote:
It is how you define mystery though, though as our policy uses Magnum PI as an example for Mystery, I'd be willing to change drama into mystery.

FYI, that example uses the old show. I wrote the policy before the new show was announced. (Maybe I should change that example so it's less confusing) I do think Drama needs to be there. We can debate back and forth over which is better, Mystery or Crime, but the show is first and foremost a drama. 

Try 30 days of free premium.