Guest Stars John Ventimiglia as Detective Eddy Costa Rebecca De Mornay as Dorothy Walker Rachel McKeon as Char Aneesh Sheth as Gillian Kevin Chacon as Vido Arocho Jessica Frances Dukes as Grace Chris McGinn as Sharon John Benjamin Hickey as Peter Lyonne Matt Weiss as Andrew Brandt Nancy Lemenager as Cassie's Mom Alan Mingo Jr. as Host #1 Max Miller as Frat Bro #1 Rileigh McDonald as Cassie Yasdan Banji Aborisade as Frat Bro #2 Rafael Poueriet as Pedestrian Harley Yeager as Surfer Cristala Carter as Reporter Greg Abbey as Mitch Yasdan Dante Costabile as Cody Willamet Janette Barber as Host #2 McLean Peterson as Girlfriend Breanna Timana as Screaming Child