Guest Stars Josh Stewart as The Watcher / Will / Joshua Guillermo Diaz as Detective Frank Cordero Reggie Lee as Dr. Francis Chiles Katelyn Tarver as Natalie Poston Co Starring Holly Hannula as News Announcer / Reporter Rod Keller as Segment Producer J.R. Nutt as Mensa Member #2 Tatum Shank as Cop Anastasia Basil as Owner Matt Yuan as Mensa Member #1 Christopher Bello as Paul Parillo Phillip Vaden as Techie Asha K. as Reporter