Guest Stars Leonardo Nam as Felix Lutz Ptolemy Slocum as Sylvester Louis Herthum as Peter Abernathy Steven Ogg as Rebus Demetrius Grosse as Deputy Foss Brian Howe as Sheriff Pickett Currie Graham as Craig Lena Georgas as Lori Bradford Tatum as Bartender / New Abernathy Michael Wincott as Old Bill Kyle Bornheimer as Clarence Eddie Rouse as Kissy Co Starring Jeff Daniel Phillips as Tenderloin Timothy Lee DePriest as Walter Jackie Moore as Hooker Brook Kerr as Woman on Train Joshua Sawtell as Controller Olivia May as Hooker Alex Marshall-Brown as Hooker Regi Davis as Father of Young Boy Stefanie Chin as Girlfriend Bridgid Coulter as Mother of Young Boy Patrick Quinlan as Passenger Molly Schreiber as Bachelorette Bianca Lopez as Diagnostic Programmer Trevante Rhodes as Bachelor Mataeo Mingo as Boy of 8 Micky Shiloah as Bachelor Nihan Gur as Female Laughing Host Keller Wortham as Bachelor Bradley Snedeker as Passenger Jeffrey Muller as Man on Train