Guest Stars Adina Porter as Lee Harris Shannon Lucio as Diana Cross Jamie Martz as Bodycam Officer Taissa Farmiga as Sophie Green Jon Bass as Milo Michael Whaley as Detective Jacob Artist as Todd Alan Connor Co Starring Fred Koehler as Real Lot Polk Susan Berger as Real Butcher Frank Collison as Real Ishmael Polk Chelsea Alden as Alissa Billy Snow as Uber Driver / Rhett Snow Christopher Allen as Officer Benton Marlon Correa as Officer Costa Alexis Jacknow as Engle