Guest Stars Adrianne Palicki as Jessica Moore Chelan Simmons as Jill Marnette Patterson as Charlie Kristie Marsden as Donna Shoemaker Duncan Minett as Steven Shoemaker William S. Taylor as Detective Co Starring Jovanna Burke as Bloody Mary / Mary Worthington Jessica King as Girl #1 Victoria Tennant as Girl #2 Genevieve Buechner as Lily Shoemaker Michael Teigen as Teacher James Ashcroft as Coroner